Peter Goonan @GoonanPeter
Reporter with The Republican and http://t.co/FRUJPzr3LT. Have notepad, will scribble things down. Masslive.com Springfield,Ma Joined December 2011-
Tweets297
-
Followers577
-
Following150
-
Likes35
Brightwood-Lincoln Elementary School is a ‘dream turned into reality’ for Springfield students, families masslive.com/springfield/20…
Springfield to pay $6.5 million in Mark Schand wrongful imprisonment case masslive.com/police-fire/20…
Still time to vote: Bright Nights in Springfield part of nationwide poll for best holiday lighting display masslive.com/entertainment/…
‘Steady hand at the wheel’: Springfield state Rep. Bud Williams cruises to victory in 11th Hampden District masslive.com/politics/2020/…
Police officer convicted of assaulting high school student and falsifying police report should be fired, Springfield City Council President Justin Hurst says masslive.com/police-fire/20…
Springfield pump station malfunction triggers 90,000-gallon wastewater release into Connecticut River masslive.com/news/2019/09/s…
Public mourns Green Beret Luis DeLeon-Figueroa along flag-adorned processional route masslive.com/news/2019/09/p…
‘Eye-opening’ experience: MGM Springfield employees see casino as oasis of opportunity masslive.com/mgmspringfield…
Too dangerous? Springfield councilors call for pedestrian-activated traffic light on State Street outside library masslive.com/news/2019/08/t…
Low-interest loans assisted two new downtown restaurants; Springfield seeks more applicants masslive.com/business/2019/…
Springfield city clerk finalist twice suspended by Board of Bar Overseers masslive.com/news/2019/07/s…
‘It’s BS,’ Moriarty’s Pub owner says after Springfield License Commission orders 8-day shutdown masslive.com/news/2019/07/i…
After years of anticipation, Springfield dedicates 9/11 memorial at Riverfront Park s.masslive.com/KDhqp9l
Springfield’s Riverfront Park reopens after $3.1 million renovation project s.masslive.com/WT8yQXT
MGM Springfield fined $100,000 for minors on gambling floor s.masslive.com/w0EO05D
‘Slap in the face:’ Labor unions demonstrate for local jobs as major renovation project proceeds at Skyview Downtown apartments in Springfield s.masslive.com/eH4wgJf
Drowsy driver blamed for crash that damaged Springfield police kiosk at Riverfront Park s.masslive.com/mVDmahd
Springfield City Council considers postcards, robocalls to boost dismal voter turnout s.masslive.com/6zlgAVB
Springfield police officer removed from school security unit due to alleged ‘misconduct’ involving student s.masslive.com/GzokaET
Power restored at Baystate Medical Center in Springfield after 2-hour outage s.masslive.com/0mycpXk
Matt Szafranski @MSzafranski413
3K Followers 3K Following Attorney; Editor-in-Chief, @WMassPI; #Spfldpoli when you need it; #MaPoli when you want it. RT ≠ Seal of Approval. Likes = ??? Fasten your seatbelt, please.Cynthia Simison @CynthiaSimison
1K Followers 971 Following Executive Editor, The Republican, Springfield, Massachusetts; [email protected]Leon Nguyen @LeonNguyen1708
416 Followers 766 Following digital & social media coordinator: AIC • former staff photographer: The Springfield Republican • photographer | videographer | video editor: Leon StudioSpringfield Thunderbi.. @ThunderbirdsAHL
16K Followers 489 Following welcome to the Thunderdome⚡️ | @stlouisblues affiliate | #WeAre413SpiritofSpringfield @SpiritofSpfld
2K Followers 477 Following Spirit of Springfield has been entertaining and enlightening hundreds of thousands annually with family-friendly events since 1990.The Big E @TheBigEFair
12K Followers 317 Following The largest event on the East Coast 🎡 Sept. 13-29 #TheBigEBrightNights @BrightNightsFP
891 Followers 290 Following Northeast's Premier Holiday Lighting Experience featuring more than 700,000 lights along a 3-mile drive. Unique displays. Rides, gifts, snacks, and more!Tamara Sacharczyk @NBC10_Tamara
6K Followers 1K Following Anchor/ I-Team reporter for @nbc10 in #Providence 📺Retweets not endorsements. #EmersonCollege alum - Story ideas👉[email protected]Jim Kinney @JimKinney413
1K Followers 1K Following Reporter at The Republican and https://t.co/eewBeWMF9RMGM Springfield @MGMSpringfield
12K Followers 816 Following The best of Las Vegas has come to the heart of New England. There's #AlwaysAReason to visit, safely. Must be 21+ to enter casino and South End Market.George Lenker @GeoLenk
1K Followers 2K Following Wannabe monk, failed songwriter, hack poet, unhealthy vegan, dog pal, misses his beloved TJ. 🐾 🐾Reminder Publishing @TheReminderMA
2K Followers 856 Following Community newspaper and media company serving Western Massachusetts. We are hometown news.Patrick Johnson @PaddyJ1325
3K Followers 2K Following I'm a world-famous A-list celebrity who refuses to buy a blue check. Also PaddyJ on https://t.co/hgZqhT5fPe if this site implodes.Matt Vautour @MattVautour424
5K Followers 4K Following Sports columnist for https://t.co/1wcNbGJ4GW Practical idealist. All opinions are my own and occasionally right. I enjoy taking panoramic pictures a bit too muchstephbarry1287 @stephbarry1287
974 Followers 268 Following Sometimes I'm a breaking news reporter. Sometimes an investigative reporter. Sometimes features. But always a reporter. Republican/MassLive.comBaystate Health @Baystate_Health
5K Followers 933 Following Our mission is to improve the health of the people in our communities every day, with quality and compassion. #AdvancingCare #EnhancingLivesChris Maza @Mazasmusings
1K Followers 2K Following Managing Editor, @TheReminderMA. Board prez, @fosteringAOK. Creator, Maza's Musings podcast. Husband, dad, brewer, Disney fan. Opinions=mine. RTs≠endorsementsKasstle The Patriot @KiessJeannie
3K Followers 7K Following $KasstleK **Investigator of rabbit🐇 holes** ✝️ ᘜOᗪ, ᖴᗩᗰIᒪY & ᙀSᗩ🇺🇸🇮🇱 Right to Life✬𝟷𝙰 & 𝟸𝙰✬ ❥VETS❥ 𝙼𝙰𝙶𝙰💎Looking 4 A good MAN🦾 № Porn-❌🛑Spam DMOswald Stone @OswaldS85646040
156 Followers 492 FollowingSmetheigh @Smetheigh176675
110 Followers 1K FollowingPhilomena @thadepy28713
278 Followers 5K Following See the world on the road, and get to know yourself on the way!susanna @susanna2971052
503 Followers 1K FollowingCelia @zhangli24696190
39 Followers 313 Following #Innovative Technology and Skin Care Philosophy of High-end Skin Care Products #High-end Makeup Gives Women Confidence and Charm #Development and Future TrendsMarx Commy @MarxCommy
2K Followers 4K Following Satire page even though I realize it may seem true I promise this page is satire. Also, a widely known and respected author. Enjoy and fight for liberalism!Sakerh Dhethan @SakerhD1420
50 Followers 111 FollowingTatiana Tonella @tats_709
107 Followers 478 Following I am a professional with sixteen years of experience in the trading industry with an in-depth knowledge and passion for international trade and markets.Juliet Schulman-Hall @JSchulmanHall
319 Followers 286 Following higher ed reporter @masslivenews | poetry, creative writing | ✍🏼 @vtdigger @NextAvenue @msmagazine @DailyHampGaz + | @smithcollege alumli huang @catbui161079
156 Followers 1K Following Design is not just what it looks like and feels like. Design is how it worksJustin Hurst @Hurst4Mayor
309 Followers 648 Following Running to be our next Mayor of Springfield, MA. Current City Councilor, working to rebuild, renew, and reimagine the City of Springfield.Apple Country Radio @AppleCntryRadio
257 Followers 1K Following Apple Country Radio is a non-commercial LPFM community radio station broadcasting from Brookfield, MA.Spfdcomiccon @spfdcomiccon
36 Followers 108 Following OFFICIAL ACCOUNT 🗯 Springfield’s Comic & Pop Culture Convention 🗯 🗓 JULY 15-16, 2023 | Massmutual Center PASSES ON SALE NOW! 👇Simply Master Service.. @SimplyMaster_OR
32 Followers 144 Following Simply Master Services is a professional cleaning company in Springfield, Oregon. We offer cleaning services to both residential and commercial areas.Meena's @eenadegracia
79 Followers 563 FollowingPrincess C. @ClazzxyPage12
6 Followers 109 Following Hii classsy glamorous model heree'. Looove takiin pictures ❤️.-Nyc and Londonn' 💙💙Bret💛Misha @BretMish
68 Followers 293 FollowingJeff Morneau @JeffreyMorneau
256 Followers 788 Following Husband, Father, Attorney @ Connor & Morneau, LLP, Past President of the @HampdenCtyBar, Progressive Democratic Candidate for #8thGovsCouncilMy @My88181195
36 Followers 1K FollowingDorcas Lee @DorcasL24453460
46 Followers 278 FollowingMA Hunger Free Campus.. @CollegeHungerMA
216 Followers 259 Following Addressing food insecurity among high-need populations enrolled in MA public colleges & universitiesPEACE2THENATION @erik_berthelsen
21 Followers 296 Following When will it end, when will politicians stop acting like children and start working for the nation. Not a Republican, Not a Democrat. Don't label me.Damaso Martinez @DamasoM74960387
80 Followers 643 FollowingDanika Hollis @Danika_Hollis1
12 Followers 95 Following If you love conservative women, raise your glass. If not, raise your standards.Terry White @TerryWh18399036
1 Followers 323 FollowingJacob bales @Jacobbales04
144 Followers 672 FollowingDotcomdotcom @Dotcomdotcom6
29 Followers 29 FollowingDavid Gregory @DavidGregoryMO
1K Followers 440 Following Stay Young | Stay Tough | Stay Loyal | Candidate for State Senate | Missouri State Rep. District 96 | Attorney | Accountant | MBA | #molegLinda Sloan @LindamariahS
3 Followers 144 Following wife,mama of 2💪🏻💞 Loves the beach, sunshine,and nature🌳 Works in real estate 💅🏻🙏🏻🌻 #republican4life 🇺🇸 #liveluaghlove # mamabearSteven Appleby @StevenAppleby16
320 Followers 368 Following𝓘𝓻𝓲𝓼𝓱�.. @Jennife97520611
149 Followers 357 Following 𝓟𝓻𝓸𝓾𝓭 𝓘𝓻𝓲𝓼𝓱, 𝓡𝓮𝓹𝓾𝓫𝓵𝓲𝓬𝓪𝓷. 𝓛𝓸𝓿𝓮 𝓐𝓷𝓲𝓶𝓪𝓵𝓼 𝓲 𝓱𝓪𝓿𝓮 3 𝓹𝓻𝓮𝓬𝓲𝓸𝓾𝓼 𝓵𝓪𝓫𝓻𝓪𝓭𝓸𝓻 𝓻𝓮𝓽𝓻𝓲𝓮𝓿𝓮𝓻𝓼 𝓤𝓢𝓐! NO DM.Young Astronauts Club @yacarrythmia
276 Followers 1K Following 21st century music. "Arrhythmia" - out now on all streaming platforms. Brought to you by Michael Macintosh, Crystal Macintosh & The Macintosh Corporation.Dawn Doherty @DawnDoherty
1 Followers 1K FollowingThe.Happy.Realist @Free_2B_Happy_
5K Followers 5K Following 🇺🇸✌🇺🇸✌🇺🇸✌🇺🇸✌🇺🇸✌🇺🇸✌🇺🇸✌ UofO Go Ducks! #Conservationist Your dog ❤ me 🐾 AGBF=Jeep 👋 Passing u by on a trail in 🇺🇲 (Notdesperatemoveon)Christian Bergland @sikolnam
60 Followers 921 FollowingGodLover21 @LoverOfGod1901
50 Followers 140 Following God #1🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 Avid church goer Child of Christ Ephesians 5:31 I stand with AutismSpeaksOmni Corp Labs @omnicorplabs
43 Followers 352 FollowingIsi Frank Ativie @IFAPrince1
404 Followers 1K Following Freelance Journalist @HydeParkHerald @LCNewsSunSport|Essayist|Content Writer|For more writing opportunities: [email protected]Michael Ampwell @MAmpwell
25 Followers 148 FollowingAlison Kuznitz @AlisonKuznitz
2K Followers 3K Following @Statehousenews reporter | @PSUBellisario @DailyCollegian 💙 | Past: @masslivenews @theobserver @BostonGlobe @hartfordcourant | 📬: [email protected]Will Katcher @will_katcher
651 Followers 1K Following Reporter for @MassLiveNews / Proud state school alum via @UMassAmherst / Always available at [email protected] or [email protected].Donald @Donald27362854
61 Followers 373 FollowingMatt Szafranski @MSzafranski413
3K Followers 3K Following Attorney; Editor-in-Chief, @WMassPI; #Spfldpoli when you need it; #MaPoli when you want it. RT ≠ Seal of Approval. Likes = ??? Fasten your seatbelt, please.Western Mass News @WMassNews
64K Followers 475 Following Western Mass News brings you news, First Warning Weather, Sports on-air, online, and on the go.Leon Nguyen @LeonNguyen1708
416 Followers 766 Following digital & social media coordinator: AIC • former staff photographer: The Springfield Republican • photographer | videographer | video editor: Leon StudioSpiritofSpringfield @SpiritofSpfld
2K Followers 477 Following Spirit of Springfield has been entertaining and enlightening hundreds of thousands annually with family-friendly events since 1990.Ryan Walsh @PIO_SPD
1K Followers 55 Following Public Information Officer for the Springfield, MA Police Department. Official Twitter Page for the Springfield Police Department. https://t.co/yQ7dDt102wThe Big E @TheBigEFair
12K Followers 317 Following The largest event on the East Coast 🎡 Sept. 13-29 #TheBigETamara Sacharczyk @NBC10_Tamara
6K Followers 1K Following Anchor/ I-Team reporter for @nbc10 in #Providence 📺Retweets not endorsements. #EmersonCollege alum - Story ideas👉[email protected]Jim Kinney @JimKinney413
1K Followers 1K Following Reporter at The Republican and https://t.co/eewBeWMF9RLindsay Iadeluca @Lindsayiadeluca
8K Followers 624 Following Mental Health advocate & current LMHC grad student. Food fam @rhodyfoody and MUA 💄🍝 Subscribe👇🏽Opinions are mineMGM Springfield @MGMSpringfield
12K Followers 816 Following The best of Las Vegas has come to the heart of New England. There's #AlwaysAReason to visit, safely. Must be 21+ to enter casino and South End Market.George Lenker @GeoLenk
1K Followers 2K Following Wannabe monk, failed songwriter, hack poet, unhealthy vegan, dog pal, misses his beloved TJ. 🐾 🐾Reminder Publishing @TheReminderMA
2K Followers 856 Following Community newspaper and media company serving Western Massachusetts. We are hometown news.Patrick Johnson @PaddyJ1325
3K Followers 2K Following I'm a world-famous A-list celebrity who refuses to buy a blue check. Also PaddyJ on https://t.co/hgZqhT5fPe if this site implodes.stephbarry1287 @stephbarry1287
974 Followers 268 Following Sometimes I'm a breaking news reporter. Sometimes an investigative reporter. Sometimes features. But always a reporter. Republican/MassLive.comBaystate Health @Baystate_Health
5K Followers 933 Following Our mission is to improve the health of the people in our communities every day, with quality and compassion. #AdvancingCare #EnhancingLivesChris Maza @Mazasmusings
1K Followers 2K Following Managing Editor, @TheReminderMA. Board prez, @fosteringAOK. Creator, Maza's Musings podcast. Husband, dad, brewer, Disney fan. Opinions=mine. RTs≠endorsementsMichelle Williams @MichelleTweetin
2K Followers 1K Following @ChicagoTribune Deputy Director of Audience | Previously @MassLiveNews | @UMassAmherst alum | Fan of data, deep dish and dogsTom Hanks @tomhanks
15.4M Followers 21 Following I'm that actor in some of the movies you liked and some you didn't. Sometimes I'm in pretty good shape, other times I'm not. Hey, you gotta live, you know?John Baibak @JohnBaibak
40 Followers 81 Following @WHYN560 News Director | Host of DayBreak with John Baibak on NewsRadio 560 WHYNMaria @margelski
450 Followers 2K FollowingElise Linscott @EliseLinscott
339 Followers 390 Following PR @jacobspillow. Freelance nonfiction writer and journalist. Art and travel enthusiast.Amanda Keane @AmandaKeaneTV
2K Followers 3K Following Basketball Analyst and Sideline Reporter @ESPNplus @NESN . State House Reporter @SpecNews1Worc . Retired athlete. I drop my R's when I'm not on TV.Melitza @melitzacotto
184 Followers 1K FollowingSusan Bennett @SiriouslySusan
1.7M Followers 1.4M Following Voice Actor, Singer, Keynote Speaker, and the Original voice of Siri. Representation by VOX, Inc., Los Angeles, https://t.co/NExfXtMoULJuli McDonald @julimcdonald
7K Followers 2K Following I report weeknights @ 11 on #WBZ @cbsboston 📺 MA native 🏡 mom of 3 👦🏻👦🏻👶🏻Elaine Driscoll @elainedriscoll
1K Followers 3K Following Comms & Policy @EOPSS | @Kennedy_School alum | former @MassGamingComm + @BostonPolice Comms DirectorNick @Nicktsagaris13
362 Followers 692 FollowingRichard Neal @NealForCongress
1K Followers 181 Following Serving Western and Central Mass in Congress. Official campaign page.Angela Kinsey🍩 @AngelaKinsey
637K Followers 686 Following Mom. Wife. Owner of nutty pets. Former fake accountant. Actress, Podcaster and sometimes a baker. https://t.co/uk9KndLkBdJenna Fischer @jennafischer
1.2M Followers 212 Following Podcaster, Author, Actress. Wife and Mom. Lover of bread making and drawstring pants.Ashley Afonso Coughli.. @AshleyAfonso
3K Followers 504 Following Host | Reporter | Home Designer | Wife | Mom to one human & 2 dogs | Rescue animal advocate | CT Native | @CCSU Alum | Love running 🏃🏻♀️ & chocolate 🍫 |Carla Cosenzi @CarlaCosenzi
998 Followers 1K Following Proud owner of @CountryNissan @CountryHyundai @NorthamptonVW @VolvoCarspv @GenesisNoho Love all things #WesternMAMeredith Perri @MeredithPerri
4K Followers 2K Following Managing Producer - Sports for @masslivenews | APSE Fellowship Class XI | AWSM Champions Class 20-21 | BU & @dailyfreepress alumna | she/herBrittany Murphy @BrittMurphyWMN
2K Followers 1K Following Former News Anchor 📺 PR & media pro • Momma raising 👧🏼 with👨🏼🚒 • Emerson College AlumCarrie Saldo @CarrieSaldo
723 Followers 346 Following Indy Journalist. Audio. Video. Web. I. Like. Words.Jim Pignatiello @JPignatiello
3K Followers 2K Following @MassLiveNews Deputy Editor & Senior Director/Sports and Audience Development • @APSE_sportmedia Mentor & Northeast Vice Chair • @AWSM_SportMedialil jen @LilJen719
182 Followers 477 Following introvert • coffee enthusiast • dog lover • avid readerNorthampton Police @NorthamptonPD
4K Followers 795 Following This is the official Twitter account of the Northampton Police Department. This account is not monitored 24/7. Dial 911 to report an emergency!Ken Ross (Wine Writer.. @ken_ross_413
1K Followers 906 Following Wine writer for https://t.co/iifbIZnDa5 & daily newspaper. WINE PRESS Weekly #wine reviews, interviews with winemakers & more since 2012. Reviews dance, music & art. SkierFocus Springfield @FocusSpfld
62 Followers 20 Following We are Springfield, MA's community TV station! Visit us online or stop by 1200 Main Street to find out more.Joyce Mulvaney @JoyceMulvaney
26 Followers 232 FollowingBusinessWest @BusinessWest413
3K Followers 637 Following The only locally-owned premiere business publication bringing local news, trends and information to nearly 30,000 readers in Western Mass. Follow @HCNewsSPFLDNATALIA ARBULU @natielisa77
30 Followers 117 Following Writer, former journalist, communicator at MassMutual, news addict, pop culture enthusiast.Patty Lubold @plubold
1K Followers 3K Following Mom, corporate coms strategist, former journalist, infrequent blogger @GrownandFlown / @holyokemedia Board/ @RavensFB/ @ofholyoke fan 🏈Damaris Pérez @DamarisPerez
37 Followers 66 Following Reporter for El Pueblo Latino | The RepublicanPope Francis Prep - C.. @PFcardinals
976 Followers 73 Following The official Twitter of Pope Francis Prep Athletics. Go Cardinals!Bo Sullivan @sullivan_bo
176 Followers 2K Following Chief Executive Officer Boys and Girls Club of Greater WestfieldElysia Rodriguez @elysia_rod
4K Followers 3K Following Emmy Award-winning Reporter | Current VP of Media Strategy for @BenchmarkBoston | 🇺🇸🇵🇭Juliana Mazza @julianamazzatv
9K Followers 2K Following ☀️Anchor/Reporter @7news | ☘️ Boston ⚜️Nola 🦞CT | 🐶 Puppy mom | 📧 [email protected]MA Gaming Commission @MassGamingComm
6K Followers 3K Following The MGC's mission is to regulate the legal casino, horse racing, & sports wagering industries with integrity & transparency.Melissa Hanson @Melissa__Hanson
4K Followers 4K Following Writer in Massachusetts | Find me reading tarot cards or paddle boarding when I’m not at a keyboard | Past bylines in MassLive, Lowell Sun, Boston GlobeJerold Duquette @JeroldDuquette
690 Followers 2K Following Professor of Political Science & Director, Public Policy & Management at CCSU; Founder/Senior Contributor at https://t.co/ocee9qfbpASteven Nanton @StevenNanton
19 Followers 16 FollowingPatty Jack @pattyjackkk
19 Followers 113 FollowingLucas Ropek @LucasRopek1
1K Followers 3K Following Writer and blogger @gizmodo, covering cybersecurity, privacy, AI, other tech stuff. Opinions/RTs are my own. Send tips and complaints to [email protected].Columbia Gas of Massa.. @ColumbiaGasMA
2K Followers 262 Following Columbia Gas of MA is now Eversource at @EversourceMA. For customer service, call 800-688-6160. To report a gas odor or emergency, call 911 and 800-525-8222.Mike Albano @mikealbano2016
567 Followers 443 Following Dad, dog owner, Governor's Councillor, fmr. Mayor of Springfield and candidate for Sheriff of Hampden CountyIn partnership with the @SpfldMACityHall and Friends of the Homeless, we are helping support the homeless with a COVID-19 testing site. Thank you to our team for jumping in to support this vulnerable population. We are proud of all you do!
So you mean to tell me, that if Clemson and LSU face off in the play offs it'll be the Tigers of Death Valley vs the Tigers of Death Valley...
Wanna wish a Happy 63rd Birthday to my dad!!! He's a good man with a great sense of humor. Love ya Pops! ift.tt/2JwuzKs
Learn something new, explore the world around you, get more done, and be in the moment for the moments that matter most, all with a little help from Google. See all the ways our products can help at g.co/helpful
Just because it's below freezing outside doesn't mean it's safe to go on ice wwlp.com/news/local-new…
Me preparing for these -25 to -35 degree temps..... facebook.com/BrittMurphyWMN…
@britnidlc 15 years ago - before Springfield got rid of its street alarm boxes - every time the scanner said there was a fire, and it was reported from a box, it turned out to be a false alarm. Every. Single. Time
.@RepRichardNeal secures House Ways and Means chairmanship #MApoli bit.ly/2GuxHbl
Letters to Santa? Nope. Patches for Ava! @WMassNews @WorcesterFD
.@SenWarren trails Joe Biden, other potential 2020 Democrats in favorability, @QuinnipiacPoll finds #MApoli bit.ly/2EFQ2kh
So there’s been a lot going on but I just want to say, I was grateful to have the opportunity to play on that stage yesterday. Thank you ❤️
Duron Harmon discusses penalty on DeAndre Hopkins hit: 'I feel it was a clean tackle' (video) blog.masslive.com/patriots/2018/…
#NationalDogDay - Olivia and Elliot just after getting a bath. They’re not even one yet!
I need @Maini_Isabella back on the morning shift because no one understands my makeup issues. I lost my brow brush and it’s tragic. 😐
White people: watch the Starbucks arrest video. See the white folks arguing with the police and asking why two innocent black men were being arrested? THIS is how you use your privilege. Because if one of us had said something we’d get arrested too.
@peterbakernyt @nytmike Maggie Haberman besmirched the integrity of other reporters. She's shown where she stands. Where is your criticism of her?