While most tobacco products will attract 40% GST in Inida, Bidis are an exception: Interestingly, the GST on bidis has been reduced from 28% to 18%. This is seen as a move to protect the domestic bidi industry and the livelihoods of bidi rollers - without considering that bidis are often more dangerous to the smoker. But this policy choice presents a significant and dangerous contradiction. Health vs. Economics: The Misconception: Bidis are often perceived as a "less harmful" alternative to cigarettes. This is a dangerous myth. Studies have consistently shown that bidis can be even more harmful. Due to their design, bidi smokers have to inhale more deeply and frequently to keep them lit, leading to a higher intake of tar, carbon monoxide, and nicotine than from a regular cigarette. The Human Cost: The public health consequences of bidi smoking are staggering, contributing to a massive burden of cancer, respiratory disease, and cardiovascular problems in India. This tax cut, by making bidis more affordable, could encourage consumption and add to this already immense health crisis. The Worker Reality: The argument for protecting bidi rollers' livelihoods also overlooks the grim reality of their working conditions. Bidi rolling is a low-wage, exploitative industry where workers, including children, are exposed to hazardous tobacco dust and suffer from chronic health issues. The industry's economic contribution to the national GDP is minuscule compared to the immense public health costs it imposes. This tax reduction highlights a critical policy challenge: how to balance economic support for a traditional, labor-intensive industry with the undeniable public health imperative to reduce tobacco use. Are there not more sustainable and safer ways to support these workers, such as providing alternative livelihood programs and vocational training? This move seems to prioritise a fragile, exploitative industry over the long-term health and well-being of the very people it claims to protect. @DrJayeshSharma @chipfoundation @SU2C @GST @India @PublicHealth @TobaccoControl @Bidi @Livelihoods @Healthcare @Policy @EconomicPolicy @SocialResponsibility